Ithaca has 9 places in our gym directory, and 7 are rated on Google at 4.4 stars on average across 398 reviews. One club owns most of that evidence. The rest of the list looks like institutional fitness centres plus two tiny studios, which changes how you should read it.
Which gyms in Ithaca have the most reviews?
| Gym | Rating | Reviews | Street, ZIP |
|---|---|---|---|
| Island Health and Fitness | 4.4 | 292 | Taughannock Blvd, 14850 |
| Noyes Fitness Center | 3.8 | 34 | West Ave, 14850 |
| Helen Newman Hall | 3.9 | 32 | Cradit Farm Dr, 14850 |
| Teagle Hall Fitness Center | 4.5 | 26 | Campus Rd, 14853 |
| Appel Fitness Center | 4.4 | 9 | Appel Commons, 14853 |
| Temple of Joy Yoga Sanctuary | 5.0 | 4 | Taylor Pl, 14850 |
| Black Irish Boxing | 5.0 | 1 | W Buffalo St, 14850 |
Island Health and Fitness has 292 of the 398 reviews, about 73 percent. Its listing also carries pool and sauna tags. At 4.4 it's the one score in Ithaca you can treat as settled.
Are the hall fitness centres open to you?
Maybe not. Noyes Fitness Center, Helen Newman Hall, Teagle Hall Fitness Center and Appel Fitness Center sit on Campus Rd, Cradit Farm Dr, West Ave and inside Appel Commons. Names and addresses like that usually belong to an institution's own facilities, and those often limit access to their members. We don't hold their access rules, so ask before you plan around one. Their scores are modest anyway: 3.8 to 4.5 from 9 to 34 reviews.
Teagle Hall at 4.5 from 26 is the best of the four. Temple of Joy Yoga Sanctuary (5.0, 4 reviews) is a yoga studio, and Black Irish Boxing (5.0, 1 review) has a single vote behind its score. Neither number tells you much.
So for a typical public membership, the data leaves you with one clear option. Is that a problem? In a town this size, a single well-reviewed club with a pool may be all most people need.
How much does a gym cost in Ithaca?
We hold no membership prices for Ithaca, so we won't guess. Fees are in US dollars. Ask about the monthly rate, any enrollment fee and the cancellation terms.
How complete are the records?
Two of 9 listings show opening hours, two a phone number and two a website. Five have photos, which is better than most cities. ZIP codes 14850 and 14853 cover the list.
How we read these ratings
Ratings and review counts come from Google and are refreshed regularly. With 398 reviews across seven rated places, most scores here rest on a few dozen people or fewer. For the state, seegyms across New Yorkor the fullUnited States directory. Short on options? Theworkout centerhas exercises you can do at home.